An illuminating quote from E Fromm’s “To have or to be”:
“Much of the moral and political discussion has centred on the question: To have or not to have? On the moral-religious level this meant the alternative between the ascetic life and the non-ascetic life, the latter including both productive enjoyment and unlimited pleasure. This alternative loses most of its meaning if one’s emphasis is not on the single act of behavior but on the attitude underlying it. Ascetic behavior, with its constant preoccupation with non-enjoyment, may be only the negation of strong desires for having and consuming. In the ascetic these desires can be repressed, yet in the very attempt to suppress having and consuming, the person may be equally preoccupied with having and consuming. […] In the economic and political field a similar erroneous alternative is between unrestricted inequality and absolute equality of income. If everybody’s possessions are functional and personal, then whether someone has somewhat more than another person does not constitute a social problem, for since possession is not essential, envy does not grow. On the other hand, those who are concerned with equality in the sense that each one’s share must be exactly equal to anyone else’s show that their own having orientation is as strong as ever, except that it is denied by their preoccupation with exact equality. Behind this concern their real motivation is visible: envy. Those demanding that nobody should have more than themselves are thus protecting themselves from the envy they would feel if anyone had even an ounce more of anything. What matters is that both luxury and poverty shall be eradicated; equality must not mean the quantitative equality of each morsel of material goods, but that income is not differentiated to a point that creates different experiences of life for different groups.”
I think this is bang-on in relation to the Soviet Union.
Thoughts from a bench
Обожнюю, як українські суди вирішують спори про обсяг прав і обовязків за договорами без аналізу договірних положень. На підставі загальних принципів цивільного права. А навіщо інакше.
The psychological urge to conform
Humans cannot bear being the odd ones out. In the mid-20th century, psychologists conducted the now-famous experiments showing that subjects forfeit firmly held views when they conflict with the opinions of the majority. In those experiments, the participants were shown two lines of different lengths. Unbeknownst to subjects, the participants made wrong calls when asked which line was longer. The subjects, who thought that the participants had acted in good faith, began to doubt the accuracy of their own perceptions and went with the group.
What strikes me is that the subjects stood little to lose if they held to their beliefs. At least, nothing in terms of the survival potential or societal acceptance. Feeling awkward was enough to sway them. Although as an ethical issue the length of a line hardly ranked highly in subjects’ minds, this phenomenon is still noteworthy. Telling what you believe to be false would not be considered as ethically neutral by any standard.
As a matter of fact, people’s desire for conformity has been known for a long time before the 20th century when state propaganda made them do horrible things. This wisdom is distilled in the following fine fable dating back millennia.
“Once upon a time Khidr, the teacher of Moses, called upon mankind with a warning. At a certain date, he said, all the water in the world which had not been specially hoarded, would disappear. It would then be renewed, with different water, which would drive men mad. Only one man listened to the meaning of this advice. He collected water and went to a secure place where he stored it, and waited for the water to change its character. On the appointed date the streams stopped running, the wells went dry, and the man who had listened, seeing this happening, went to his retreat and drank his preserved water. When he saw, from his security, the waterfalls again beginning to flow, this man descended among the other sons of men. He found that they were thinking and talking in an entirely different way from before; yet they had no memory of what had happened, nor of having been warned. When he tried to talk to them, he realized that they thought that he was mad, and they showed hostility or compassion, not understanding. At first he drank none of the new water, but went back to his concealment, to draw on his supplies, every day. Finally, however, he took the decision to drink the new water because he could not bear the loneliness of living, behaving and thinking in a different way from everyone else. He drank the new water, and became like the rest. Then he forgot all about his own store of special water, and his fellows began to look upon him as a madman who had miraculously been restored to sanity.” (Idries Shah, “Tales of the dervishes”).
And as Robert Greene wrote:
“we are all permeable to the influence of the group. What makes us more permeable is our insecurities. The less we are certain about our Self-worth as individuals, the more we are unconsciously drawn toward fitting in and blending ourselves into the group spirit. Gaining the superficial approval of group members by displaying our conformity, we cover up our insecurities to ourselves and to others. But this approval is fleeting; our insecurities gnaw at us, and we must continually get people’s attention to feel validated. Your goal must be to lower your permeability by raising your Self-esteem. If you feel strong and confident about what makes you unique—your tastes, your values, your own experience—you can more easily resist the group effect. Furthermore, by relying upon your work and accomplishments to anchor your Self-opinion, you won’t be so tied to constantly seeking approval and attention. It is not that you become Self-absorbed or cut off from the group—outwardly you do what you can to fit in, but inwardly you subject the ideas and beliefs of the group to constant scrutiny, comparing them with your own, adapting parts or all of those that have merit and rejecting others that go against your experience. You are putting the focus on the ideas themselves, not on where they come from.” (from “The Laws of Human Nature”)
Most effective writing tools (a tweet)
“I’ve studied the writing habits of 100+ luminaries. This is what they all shared: taking long walks.”
“Market reforms” in the Post-Soviet countries: a note from the cynic
Karl Marx went to great lengths to study the social and economic phenomena unfolding in 19-century England. In virtually all his contributions, he had built upon the work of his predecessors, being in many ways a poster boy of the reason-wielding Enlightenment. He respected Hegel but took issue with the application of his theories. He adopted A Smith’s view of labour as the main factor in creating value and extended it to form the theory of surplus-value.
While Marx had an assertive and domineering character, his followers in Western Europe predominantly yielded to the civilized rules of conversation. Thus, throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries Marx’ views were set in the proper context, i.e. as a vigorous and eloquent critique of the alternative set of ideas. To the extent that such beliefs and assumptions failed the test of scrutiny and experience, they were gradually abandoned without much regret.
An entirely different pattern of Marx’ appreciation and appropriation was taking place in the Russian Empire and, subsequently, the Soviet Union. The followers of Marxism divorced his theories from the larger context, banning or censoring anything that could look subversive, which is just about everything. And soon after Stalin’s ascent and the iron curtain’s descent, comrades stopped reading even the gospel of Marx. Marxism, mixed with a dash of Leninism, became summum bonnum not so much because it ensured that all comrades equally shared the fruits of joint efforts and new civilization, but it allowed them to lash out anger against the rich and consolidate power. Two birds with one stone.
Fast forward to the 1990s, and post-Soviet countries scrambled to outdo each other in their spectacular displays of bungled attempts to ensure a transition to a market economy. The mistakes that were made were not accidental but, if I may venture to say so, eerily proper and fitting, entirely in the nature of things. How could it be otherwise when the decades of criminalization of curiosity about Western ideas hollowed out any knowledge of market capitalism? The examples abound and would fill hundreds of pages (I’ll refer the reader, for instance, to C Freeland’s ‘Sale of the Century’). S Kotkin’s ‘Armageddon Averted’ is likewise a captivating read. Here’s one of the hundreds of steps made during the purported market reforms:
“foreign investors were excluded from the bidding [in the process of privatisaion], in a supposed bow to nationalists who decried the sale of Russia’s “patrimony.” That exclusion robbed Russia of a critical lever for assessing, and perhaps raising the worth of, its patrimony. The AvtoVAZ carmaker, for example, was purchased at voucher auction for $45 million, whereas in 1991 Fiat had offered $2 billion—and been turned away. Between 1992 and 1996, according to an investigation of hundreds of companies, on average factory management admitted paying about forty times less than their companies were supposedly worth. The investigators noted that the voucher value of all Russian industry—including some of the world’s richest deposits of natural resources—came to about $12 billion, less than the value at the time of Anheuser-Busch. Russian state property was given away for small beer, to make privatization an “irreversible” political reality.”
Quote
“Many moralists have noticed the discrepancy in modern Europe between the Law of Honour (or the more important rules maintained by the social sanction of polite persons) and the morality professed in society at large. This is, however, by no means the only instance of a special code, divergent in certain points from the moral rules generally accepted in the community where it exists. Most religious sects and parties, and probably the majority of trades and professions, exhibit this phenomenon in some degree. I do not mean merely that special rules of behaviour are imposed upon members of each profession, corresponding to their special social functions and relations: I mean that a peculiar moral opinion is apt to grow up, conflicting to a certain extent with the opinion of the general public. The most striking part of this divergence consists generally in the approval or excusal of practices disapproved by the current morality: as (e.g.) licence among soldiers, bribery among politicians in certain ages and countries, unveracity of various degrees among priests and advocates, fraud in different forms among tradesmen. In such cases there are generally strong natural inducements to disobey the stricter rule (in fact it would seem to be to the continual pressure of these inducements that the relaxation of the rule has been due): while at the same time the social sanction is weakened to such an extent that it is sometimes hard to say whether it outweighs a similar force on the other side. For a man who, under these circumstances, conforms to the stricter rule, if he does not actually meet with contempt and aversion from those of his calling, is at least liable to be called eccentric and fantastic: and this is still more the case if by such conformity he foregoes advantages not only to himself but to his relatives or friends or party. Very often this professional or sectarian excusal of immorality of which we are speaking is not so clear and explicit as to amount to the establishment of a rule, conflicting with the generally received rule: but is still sufficient to weaken indefinitely the social sanction in favour of the latter. And, apart from these special divergences, we may say generally that in most civilised societies there are two different degrees of positive morality, both maintained in some sort by common consent; a stricter code being publicly taught and avowed, while a laxer set of rules is privately admitted as the only code which can be supported by social sanctions of any great force. By refusing to conform to the stricter code a man is often not liable to incur exclusion from social intercourse, or any material hindrance to professional advancement, or even serious dislike on the part of any of the persons whose society he will most naturally seek; and under such circumstances the mere loss of a certain amount of reputation is not likely to be felt as a very grave evil, except by persons peculiarly sensitive to the pleasures and pains of reputation. And there would seem to be many men whose happiness does not depend on the approbation or disapprobation of the moralist—and of mankind in general in so far as they support the moralist—to such an extent as to make it prudent for them to purchase this praise by any great sacrifice of other goods.” (from “The Methods of Ethics” by Henry Sidgwick)
Quote of the day about elections
An illuminating quote from “Power of Persuasion” by psychologist R Levine: “[In 1980s, Brazil] was conducting its first free elections in many years. As you might expect, there was a gret deal of excitement. Campaign ads were all over television. The streets were often filled with boisterous caravans of vehicles blaring music and carrrying beautiful women holding up sings for their candidate. The only thing people didn’t hear were the candidates themselves. The reason for this, it turned out, was that the rulng military government had banned the candidates from making public statements. I wondered how voters made their decisions. (“I liked the smile on the guy followed by the car with the blonde.” Or maybe, “I’m not voting for some jerk in a Volkswagen.”) To my surprise, few Brazilians I spoke to seemed bothered by the no-talking rule. “When the politicans start saying things,” one of my friends explained, “it just confuses people”“
Makes one ponder about democracy.
What is the single biggest factor of sustained economic growth?
What is the cause of the modern wealth? Virtually all economists agree that throughout history, average incomes remained relatively flat until the 1800s. Since then, incomes per capita grew between a factor of 30 (that is, 29 000%) and 100 (99 000%). Economists disagree, however, what caused this hockey stick-like surge.
Throughout the 20th century, scholars increasingly attributed this great enrichment to culture, loosely defining it as society’s beliefs, preferences and values. Max Weber, apparently, was a trailblazer but even in Adam Smith’s theory, human psychology played a prominent role. For instance, The Economist (rightly) wrote that “Adam Smith, the author of “The Wealth of Nations”, explored the ways in which culture helped or hindered capitalism. He argued that certain norms were required in order for market economies to thrive—most importantly, that people would be self-interested, but that they would satisfy their self-interest by adapting to the needs of others.”
In “Bourgeois Dignity: Why economics can’t explain the modern world”, D McCloskey argues, quite convincingly, that the main factor of the astounding economic growth over the past two centuries is the improvement of the social standing of the merchants and bourgeoisie in general. Relying on statistical data, she consecutively dismisses as not sufficiently important factors that are espoused by rival theories of economic growth. These factors include capital accumulation (including expropriation), transport, geography, coal, trade, inheritance, and institutions.
In the opening lines of her book, D McCloskey writes “A big change in the common opinion about markets and innovation, I claim, caused the Industrial Revolution, and then the modern world. The change occurred during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries in northwestern Europe. More or less suddenly the Dutch and British and then the Americans and the French began talking about the middle class, high or low – the “bourgeoisie” – as though it were dignified and free. The result was modern economic growth.” According to D McCloskey, not capital accumulation (necessary but not sufficient for long-term growth) but innovation leads to the increase of the economic pie. Innovation (with a small “i”) is a spontanous, bottom-up process that requires a high degree of economic security and liberty. Vast improvements of living standards resulted from small tweaks and improvements, not the inventions of the likes of light bulb or Internet. This comes with respect of workers who do the often unnoticed work.
It is probably true that during the past two hundred years, the social status of traders, craftsmen, inventors etc did rise from the lows where it had been for the most part of the recorded history. One needs to recall that merchants were banned from participating in the political life of ancient Greece. In the Russian Empire, commercial work was relegated to Germans, Jews and other foreigners as it was deemed too lowly for the native aristocracy. Some economically stagnant countries have been or still are culturally backward (‘conservative’) and socially closed. There does seem to be a strong correlation between their rates of growth and levels of respect accorded to liberty, property and labour as well as cultural attitudes to commercial activity. After all, in the 20th century not the advanced but the backward countries championed socialism and trampled liberty and property rights.
This all makes for a good story if only with a twist. In the 18th century, a seasoned diplomat Ben Franklin wrote that in the 18th century in France and England, unlike in America, the social standing of workers wasn’t great. In his short 1792 article “Information to Those Who Would Remove to America”, he wrote: “Persons of moderate Fortunes and Capitals who, having a Number of Children to provide for, are desirous of bringing them up to Industry and to secure Estates for their Posterity, have Opportunities of doing it in America which Europe does not afford. There they may be taught & practice profitable mechanic Arts without incurring Disgrace on that Account ¾ but on the contrary acquiring Respect by such Abilities.”
Ben Franklin was unquestionably qualified to pass that judgment since he spent well over 10 years mingling with the middle class of England in France! Even according to D McCloskey he was the paragon of prudence and other modern bourgeois virtues. So could cultural attitudes in France and England improve within one or two generations?
Perhaps attributing modern economic conditions to a single important factor is fallacious. A critical thinker R Dobelli wrote “[i]n 2008, panic reigned in the financial markets. Banks caved in and had to be nursed back to health with tax dollars. Investors, politicians and journalists probed furiously for the root of the crisis: Greenspan’s loose monetary policy? The stupidity of investors? The dubious rating agencies? Corrupt auditors? Bad risk models? Pure greed? Not a single one, and yet every one of these, is the cause. … The fallacy of the single cause is as ancient as it is dangerous. We have learned to see people as the ‘masters of their own destinies’. Aristotle proclaimed this 2,500 years ago. Today we know that it is wrong. The notion of free will is up for debate. Our actions are brought about by the interaction of thousands of factors – from genetic predisposition to upbringing, from education to the concentration of hormones between individual brain cells. Still we hold firmly to the old image of self-governance.”
Breaking down complex phenomena may be helpful and even necessary for a research but hardly for an exhaustive explanation.
The excellence of the ancient Greek culture
I do not marvel at the level of advencement of the ancient Greek arts and sciences. One might say that each civilisation is relatively valuable. But I do marvel how the Greco-Roman culture vastly predetermined the direction of what we call the West.
Scholars of the 12th and 13th centures regarded contemporary arts and sciences to be considerably inferior to that of the ancient Greeks. The latter moulded the Rennesaince, inspired the key figures of the Englightenmnet. It is impossible to brush this off. It is equally impossible not to be awed by this.
Internal dilemmas in the Soviet Union
Few passages from the excellent book by Stephen Kotkin Armageddon Averted: The Soviet Collapse, 1970-2000 are worth quoting in full:
“From its inception, the Soviet Union had claimed to be an experiment in socialism, a superior alternative to capitalism, for the entire world. If socialism was not superior to capitalism, its existence could not be justified. In the inter-war period, during Stalin’s violent crusade to build socialism, capitalism had seemed for many people to be synonymous with world imperialism, the senseless slaughter of the First World War, goose-stepping militarism, and Great Depression unemployment. Against that background, the idea of a non-capitalist world—with the same modern machines but supposedly with social justice—held wide appeal.“
“[T]he post-war Soviet Union tried to slake a thirst for self-contained apartments that gave people some private space, provided educational opportunities that made people both orthodox and critical, and expanded communications technologies, letting in more of the Western world. The authorities encountered a sharpening divergence between the aims of advancing science and the need to maintain secrecy for political reasons. They were also unable to energize society, especially youth, with the antiquated model of heroic mobilization, or to satisfy a growing restlessness, bordering on a sense of entitlement. But they drew upon pride in the Second World War victory, and expediently allowed nationalisms to mix with Communism, while retaining censorship. Overall, these post-war developments were not remarkable in themselves. They were, however, made potentially very dangerous by the economic boom, consumer revolution, mass cultural explosion, and embrace of democracy outside the USSR.”
“[T]he regime faced a threat considerably greater than “dissidents”: a several-million-strong army of scientists who were overwhelmingly not politically active yet still clashed with the authorities because they needed access to basic domestic data—let alone foreign publications—which were denied to them by their hack political supervisors. This dilemma of needing and yet stifling scientific exchange became ever more acute, and a few top apparatchiks broached the possibility of relaxing censorship.”
“Glasnost turned into a tsunami of unflattering comparisons because of past censorship, the obsession with the capitalist world, and the intelligentsia’s apocalyptic inclinations—it beat itself into hysteria with a competition to appear the “most radical.” The smash Friday night television variety show, Vzglyad (Viewpoint), portrayed the Soviet realm as utterly destitute and exploited, while the West came across as paved with gold and unreservedly free. A print journalist who had written one of the fiercest anti-American diatribes prior to 1985 became the editor of the mass-circulation illustrated magazine Ogonyok (Flame), and promptly turned it into the most widely read source of investigative reporting and a billboard of exaggerated pro-Americanism. Grisly new details about Communist repressions further undermined the allegiance to socialism, and raised moral dilemmas. Mass graves were described by the very policemen who had dug them. Prosecutors who had destroyed innocent people were still on the job or enjoyed comfortable retirements, while their victims were dead or suffered meager pensions. Journalists who had hounded “enemies” for anti-Soviet agitation now hastened to publish those views. All previous life was revealed as a lie.“
“By 1989 […] readers’ letters bespoke the profound disillusionment characteristic of defectors. “What sort of a government is it [that] allows only selected people to live normal family lives?” wrote M.F., from the city of Kharkov. “Why is it that people in authority have everything, flats, dachas, and money, and others have nothing? . . . I am a simple woman. I used to believe in our government. Now I no longer believe.”